Fulton Fish Market Reviews

Ordering was simple, and the pages loaded fine for me. It took me a minute, just a minute, to figure out where some of the filters were, but once I did, checkout was smooth. Overall, a good, good website experience.

The fish was really fresh and packaged well, so no complaints there. I’d order it more often, but the shipping is pricey, actually, not just pricey, it’s high enough that it makes me think twice. It’s good stuff, but the delivery cost can be hard to justify sometimes.

I was checking my order tracking one afternoon and it just didn’t seem to be updating, so I wasn’t sure if my package was actually moving or stuck somewhere. I decided to email customer service, expecting to wait a while, but they replied faster than I thought they would. They explained what was going on in a clear way, which was reassuring. The package ended up arriving the very next day with no issues. I’m taking off one star only because I had to reach out to figure it out, but overall they were helpful, friendly, and easy to deal with

I’ve been ordering from Fulton Fish Market for a while now, the biggest thing for me is that they usually have what I need in stock. The fish I tend to buy is almost always available, and if something is sold out, it seems to come back quickly.
I don’t have to bounce around between different sites or suddenly rethink dinner at the last minute — which I really appreciate. Their stock just feels reliable, and that’s a big reason I keep coming back

I ordered salmon and scallops from fultonfishmarket.com and was a little unsure about having seafood shipped to my door. But it showed up still cold, with the packaging done really well, and there wasn’t any strong fishy smell when I opened it, just that clean, fresh seafood smell. I cooked the salmon that same night, and it tasted great. The scallops were sweet and tender too, which stood out to me. Overall, I was happy with the order and would definitely try them again.

The fish was fresh and overall it’s a decent value, but I don’t have a lot of patience for shipping fees piling up at checkout. The prices are mostly fair, just a little higher than I’d like once everything gets added on.

They had scallops, salmon, and a bunch of other seafood I never see at my regular grocery store. kind of impressive. So many choices.

Everything showed up just as expected, and the order was exactly right. No issues at all, which is always a nice little win these days.

I don’t remember much about the delivery details, but I do remember opening the box and being happy with how cold the fish still was. The insulation seemed solid, and everything looked well packed.

I ordered salmon and scallops from Fulton Fish Market and was really impressed with how fresh everything tasted. The salmon was clean and buttery, and the scallops were sweet with no fishy taste at all. I cooked them the same night, they were better than what I usually find locally. I was really happy with the order and would definitely buy from them again...

I liked that there was clear info about where it’s sourced from. That small detail made me feel better about buying it. Overall, I’m happy with it...

My delivery arrived right on time, which I really appreciated because I had planned my day around the estimated window and didn’t want to be stuck waiting around forever. Everything showed up when they said it would, the process was smooth, and there weren’t any issues or surprises at all.

I ordered a few fish cuts and was surprised by how generous the portions were. They were a really good size and definitely felt worth the money. Small win for me because I ended up having enough left over for another meal.

I just placed an order on Fulton Fish Market, the checkout was really smooth. I mean, I started to double-check everything, then, actually, there wasn’t much to double-check because the cart updated right away and picking a delivery date was simple.

The payment went through fast too, and the confirmation email showed up almost instantly. It’s just nice when a site works the way you expect it to without making the whole thing a hassle.

I was pleasantly surprised by how fresh everything tasted. The salmon was really good, and overall the seafood had great quality. The shrimp were a bit smaller than I was expecting, but they still tasted nice. Happy with the order overall.

One of the fish in my order showed up looking a little off. Ugh. I sent them an email with a photo, and while it did take a bit to get a response, they were actually easy to deal with. They offered either a refund or a replacement, no hassle. Nice. I went with the replacement, and the next one arrived in good shape. Not a perfect experience, but they made it right, so I’d give them 4 stars.

I really like that I’m not locked into the same fish box every week. You can kind of tell they know people’s schedules change, because skipping, pausing, or swapping things around is straightforward. I had a trip come up and was able to skip my order without digging through a bunch of hoops. Reading between the lines, that flexibility is what makes the subscription feel practical instead of like another thing I have to manage.